Homemade. Really.
Welcome to Blue House Bakeshop! We are a licensed home bakery in Shelburne, Vermont, making custom order cakes and other sweet treats for events big and small in Vermont and beyond. Browse the menus below to get inspired for your next event’s dessert table. Submit an order form to get started!
Beatrix Hassler, Chef & Owner
Ordering a cake?
Check out our CAKE SIZE GUIDE to see what size cake might be right for your party’s size, budget, and vibes.
Custom designed buttercream cakes are our specialty. Choose any flavor cake for the inside, and add on a unique personalized buttercream design to the outside of the cake for an added charge. Look through our photo galleries to get a feel for our style and get inspired, then submit an inquiry to get started designing.
MENUS
THANKSGIVING PIES - pickup 11/26 & 11/27
SALTED MAPLE PECAN // 28
butter crust, Vermont maple, pecans, sea salt
CLASSIC PUMPKIN // 25
butter crust, creamy pumpkin filling
CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER PRETZEL // 30
pretzel crust, peanut butter mousse, chocolate ganache, whipped cream
Cupcakes from $3 - minimum order of 6 // 4-inch rounds from $40 // 6-inch rounds from $58 // 9-inch rounds from $112 // 12-inch rounds from $196
CAKES
*Optional add-ons: ganache filling, raspberry filling, vanilla cream filling, coconut cream filling
- DOUBLE CHOCOLATE -
chocolate cake + milk chocolate buttercream
*Optional add-ons: ganache filling, raspberry filling, vanilla cream filling, coconut cream filling
*Optional add-ons: rainbow sprinkles (funfetti), vanilla cream filling, raspberry filling, ganache filling, lemon curd filling, coconut cream filling
- CLASSIC VANILLA -
vanilla cake + vanilla buttercream
*Optional add-ons: rainbow sprinkles (funfetti), vanilla cream filling, raspberry filling, ganache filling, lemon curd filling, coconut cream filling
*Optional add-ons: crunchy peanut butter filling, ganache filling, vanilla cream filling
- PEANUT BUTTER MOCHA -
chocolate cake + peanut butter mocha buttercream
*Optional add-ons: crunchy peanut butter filling, ganache filling, vanilla cream filling
*Optional add-ons: poppy seeds (lemon poppy seed), lemon curd filling, raspberry filling, vanilla cream filling, coconut cream filling
- LEMON -
lemon cake + vanilla buttercream
*Optional add-ons: poppy seeds (lemon poppy seed), lemon curd filling, raspberry filling, vanilla cream filling, coconut cream filling
*Optional add-ons: walnuts, golden raisins
- MAPLE CARROT -
spiced carrot cake + cream cheese frosting + Vermont maple sugar
*Optional add-ons: walnuts, golden raisins
*Optional add-ons: coconut cream filling, vanilla cream filling, lemon curd filling, chocolate ganache filling
- COCONUT ALMOND -
coconut almond cake + vanilla buttercream
*Optional add-ons: coconut cream filling, vanilla cream filling, lemon curd filling, chocolate ganache filling
- inquire for pricing -
- CUSTOM FLAVOR -
mix and match cake, filling, and frosting flavors from above menu, or imagine something totally unique to your taste buds!
- inquire for pricing -
Cakes are 4 layers of cake with 3 layers of frosting/filling. Prices above are subject to change based on design and material upgrades. Please note, we do not use fondant on any of our cakes.
OTHER BAKES
fudgy brownies cloaked in ganache, topped with sea salt ... $2.75
- BROWNIE BITES -
fudgy brownies cloaked in ganache, topped with sea salt ... $2.75
cookie crust, vanilla pastry cream, fresh berries ... $4
- FRUIT TARTS -
cookie crust, vanilla pastry cream, fresh berries ... $4
filled with vanilla or chocolate cream, dipped in ganache ... $4
- CREAM PUFFS -
filled with vanilla or chocolate cream, dipped in ganache ... $4
chocolate cake sandwiched with vanilla buttercream filling ... $3.50
- MINI WHOOPIE PIES -
chocolate cake sandwiched with vanilla buttercream filling ... $3.50
homemade "oreos", peanut butter mocha, or brown butter vanilla ... $2.50
- SANDWICH COOKIES -
homemade "oreos", peanut butter mocha, or brown butter vanilla ... $2.50
chocolate chip, double chocolate espresso, peanut butter, ginger molasses, or oatmeal raisin ... $2.50
- DROP COOKIES -
chocolate chip, double chocolate espresso, peanut butter, ginger molasses, or oatmeal raisin ... $2.50
baked apple cider donuts tossed in cinnamon sugar ... $2.75
- CIDER DONUTS -
baked apple cider donuts tossed in cinnamon sugar ... $2.75
rectangular almond shortbread cookies made famous by Ted Lasso ... $1.75
- ALMOND SHORTBREAD -
rectangular almond shortbread cookies made famous by Ted Lasso ... $1.75
- inquire for pricing -
- CUSTOM BAKE -
go off-menu and request something tailor made to your taste preferences
- inquire for pricing -
*"Other Bakes" items have a minimum order requirement of 6 per flavor*
Many of the items above can be made without gluten, dairy, and other allergens upon request. If you have food allergies please list them on your order form.
See below for examples of our cake sizes
View fullsize
Cupcakes from $3, minimum order 6
View fullsize
4" Cakes from $40 - Serves 8
View fullsize
6" Cakes from $58 - Serves 12
View fullsize
9" Cakes from $112 - Serves 32
View fullsize
12" Cakes from $196 - Serves 56
View fullsize
6"+4" Cakes from $160 - Serves 20
View fullsize
9"+6" Cakes from $352 - Serves 44
View fullsize
12"+9" Cakes from $704 - Serves 88
View fullsize
9"+6"+4" Cakes from $416 - Serves 52
View fullsize
12"+9"+6" Cakes from $800 - Serves 100
View fullsize
12"+9"+6"+4" Cakes from $864 - Serves 108